The “Revolving Door” between Regulatory Agencies and Industry: A Problem That Requires Reconceptualizing Objectivity

There is a “revolving door” between federal agencies and the industries regulated by them. Often, at the end of their industry tenure, key industry personnel seek employment in government regulatory entities and vice versa. The flow of workers between the two sectors could bring about good. Industry veterans might have specialized knowledge that could be useful to regulatory bodies and former government employees could help businesses become and remain compliant with regulations. But the “revolving door” also poses at least three ethical and policy challenges that have to do with public trust and fair representation. First, the presence of former key industry personnel on review boards could adversely impact the public’s confidence in regulatory decisions about new technology products, including agrifood biotechnologies. Second, the ‘‘revolving door’’ may result in policy decisions about technologies that are biased in favor of industry interests. And third, the ‘‘revolving door’’ virtually guarantees industry a voice in the policy-making process, even though other stakeholders have no assurance that their concerns will be addressed by regulatory agencies. We believe these three problems indicate a failure of regulatory review for new technologies. The review process lacks credibility because, at the very least, it is procedurally biased in favor of industry interests. We argue that prohibiting the flow of personnel between regulatory agencies and industry would not be a satisfactory solution to the three problems of public trust and just representation. To address them, regulatory entities must reject the traditional notion of objectivity. Instead they should adopt the conception of objectivity developed by Sandra Harding and re-configure their regulatory review on the basis of it. That will ensure that a heterogeneous group of stakeholders is at the decision-making table. The fair representation of interests of different constituencies in the review process could do much to inspire warranted public confidence in regulatory protocols and decisions.     

Composite Film Based on Whey Protein Isolate/Pectin/CuO Nanoparticles/Betanin Pigments; Investigation of Physicochemical Properties

Journal of Polymers and the Environment - The aim of this work was to preparation of edible films based on whey protein isolate/pectin (WPIP) that containing betanin pigments (BP) and copper (I)...     

A Novel Aloe Vera-Loaded Ethylcellulose/Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose Nanofibrous Mat Designed for Wound Healing Application

Journal of Polymers and the Environment - Newly, the usage of nanofibers (NFs) as wound dressings with the aim of their rapid healing and prevention of bacterial infection has been considered by...     

Performance evaluation of sustainable projects: a possibilistic integrated novel analytic hierarchy process-data envelopment analysis approach using Z-Number information

Environment, Development and Sustainability - Selecting a proper set of projects is an important issue to make crucial decisions for many project-oriented organizations enabling them to achieve...     

Carbon footprint calculation in one of the largest Gas Refinery Companies in the Middle East

Environmental Science and Pollution Research - Rapid technological advances in the natural gas industry raised access to natural gas reserves, related to increased greenhouse gas emissions,...     

Health risk assessment of inhalation exposure to dry fogging of hydrogen peroxide in a dental clinic during the COVID-19 pandemic

Environmental Science and Pollution Research - After the outbreak of COVID-19, many dental clinics use dry fogging of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) to disinfect the air and surfaces. Inhalation of...     

Fabrication of a Novel Fibrous Mat Based on Gliadin/Ethylcellulose Incorporated with Triamcinolone for Treatment of Oral Ulcers

Journal of Polymers and the Environment - Eelectrospun fibrous mats for oral ulcer dressing should be able to attach oral mucosa in a high moisture environment and provide desirable therapeutic...     

Hydrochemical evaluation of groundwater quality and human health risk assessment of trace elements in the largest mining district of South Khorasan,Eastern Iran

Environmental Science and Pollution Research - The groundwater resources of mining areas have been in a challenging condition in terms of metal pollution and human health. Therefore, this study...     

Fabrication of Nano Zero valent Iron/Biopolymer Composite with Antibacterial Properties for Simultaneous Removal of Nitrate and Humic Acid: Kinetics and Isotherm Studies

Journal of Polymers and the Environment - This investigation compared the adsorption behavior of humic acid (HA) on cellulose, chitosan and nano zerovalent iron/chitosan (nZVI/chitosan). Results...